SIGN IN

Promoting Quality in Teacher Education

Student Teachers on the brink: a provocation concerning ITE poverty

The UCET Intellectual Base of Teacher Education (UCET, 2020) states that high-quality teacher education ‘encourages a lifelong commitment to the education profession and pays careful attention to the factors that promote a healthy learning environment for teachers and learners’ (p.2). Currently, data suggests that many of our student teachers are not living in healthy environments.

The number of students experiencing poverty is becoming a major concern, with many universities reporting increased demand for support with basic living expenses, food banks and emergency financial assistance. More recent findings from the National Union of Students (2024), referring to university students more broadly, indicated that 41% rely on financial help from family and 54% have reduced their food spending. In addition, most undergraduate and postgraduate students in England now undertake part-time work to support themselves financially (NUS, 2024). The NUS (2024) data for the wider student population shows that three-in-five students are employed alongside their studies; one third of these work more than 20 hours per week. Sixty one percent of working students say their job negatively affects their studies, with 9% reporting a major impact.

There is no national data set specifically focused on student teachers, poverty and employment, and the lack of research in this area is a pressing issue in itself (Mclaren et al., 2025). However, given the additional financial pressures that student teachers face, including the cost of travelling to school placements, it is reasonable to assume that these figures and trends apply to student teachers, and potentially at even higher rates. The NUS also notes that financial pressures are more acute for postgraduate students, who make up the majority of student teachers.

We know from our own work with student teachers in the North of England that financial and employment pressures are a significant issue. We hear from student teachers frequently about unexpected costs such as car repairs and emergency childcare, as well as the rising costs of living that make their well-planned finances suddenly inadequate. One of our student teachers told us that despite carefully planning childcare plans for the whole PGCE period, (including back-up plans), emergency childcare was needed during their first placement which meant they could not afford to pay the mortgage and bills. Another told us that car repairs meant that without an emergency loan from the university, they would need to withdraw from the programme. In both cases, the universities concerned stepped in to provide emergency funding, but these situations are becoming more common and even with a solution, are stressful. These are the hidden costs of training.

Specific issues that we have identified that are affecting student teachers include:

  • travel costs, car maintenance;
  • Rising costs of living, including food prices, energy and fuel;
  • Wellbeing whilst holding down a job alongside UG/PG ITE study, especially for non or low ITT bursary student teachers;
  • Caring responsibilities (children, siblings, parents) where childcare and social care are no longer an option in the area the student teacher lives;
  • Regional disparities in terms of accommodation costs, and rising housing costs generally.

Given the above geographical and contextual threats to recruitment and retention, we would like to pose some questions for policymakers and for the UCET membership:

  • Are we currently pricing out some graduates from entering the profession? What research is being done on the lived experience of student teachers who are not given financial support to train?
  • How can we continue to diversify the profession when some do not qualify for ITT bursary support?
  • Do we run the risk of making our profession elitist, with only those with financial support able to successfully navigate the non-academic demands of the ITE training period?

References

Mclaren, E., Gibson, L. & McKinney, S. (2025) Poverty experienced by initial teacher education students in Scotland. Scottish Educational Review, (doi: 10.1163/27730840-bja10027) (Early Online Publication)

National Union of Students (NUS) (2024) Cost of Living Report – Spring 2024, NUS website, report Available at: https://assets.nationbuilder.com/nus/pages/3037/attachments/original/1718181936/NUS_UK_Cost_of_Living_2024_report.pdf (Accessed 26 June 2026)

Ovenden-Hope, T., Brown, V., and Walsh, R. (2025) Teach Cornwall Report.

Place-based challenges for trainee teacher recruitment. Plymouth Marjon University, Plymouth.

Universities’ Council for the Education of Teachers (UCET). (2020). The Intellectual Base of Teacher Education Report. https://www.ucet.ac.uk/11675/intellectual-base-of-teacher-education-report

About the authors

Photo of Claire E-Ball Smith

Professor Claire E Ball-Smith

University of York

More about Claire

Claire Ball-Smith (University of York)

Claire has worked in schools, universities and educational organisations for the last 30 years. As a history and English teacher she worked in the UK, as well as in Africa. As a teacher educator, she has worked at three UK universities and one in Canada. Claire is currently a Senior Lecturer, and the Director of Initial Teacher Training at the University of York.

Claire served on the national Historical Association secondary committee as a History PGCE tutor and set up the West Yorkshire branch of the HA as a teacher. Her first love is history teaching, having worked as a History and Social Studies teacher educator for over a decade before moving into more senior ITE management positions. She chairs the Professional Programmes Forum at the University of York and sits on the University's Senate as an elected member. She also sits on the University's Apprenticeship Steering Group.

Claire's research interests are in history education; the beginner trainee's identity and its consequent influence on the teacher they then become; and models and types of mentoring. Her most recent chapter explores the types of mentors that exist in English schools, and how their strengths can be best harnessed to benefit as challenge trainees placed within ITE partnerships.

Claire is the new Chair of UCET.

Photo of Aimee Quickfall

Professor Aimee Quickfall

Durham University

More about Aimee

Aimee is Director of Initial Teacher Training in the School of Education at Durham University.

Aimee’s research interests include teacher careers and life stories, teacher and trainee teacher well-being and workload and broader issues around research ethics and gender in education.